
I have become somewhat fascinated by American Idol, much to my chagrin. I blame it on the fact the ITV2 run repeats of it all the time over the weekend, so you catch it at some point and then it sucks you in. In general I disapprove of these type of shows wholeheartedly - people getting record deals on the back of a public vote on TV, when some musicians who are supremely talented have to struggle for years. And the kind of music that I like isn't represented in any case. It's populist nonsense - the Man write large.
But still, all this aside, I have become absolutely fascinated by it. I have to decide on a Thursday whether or not to check to see who has been voted off (the main show airs in the US on a Tuesday and then the results show is on the Wednesday, but the corresponding shows don't air in the UK until Wednesday and Thursday respectively). Usually, I can't resist the urge.
I love watching it. Listening to the judges rambling on about "artistry" or "pitchiness" or saying "you know I love you, but I didn't love that song choice for you", or counting how many times Randy Jackson says "yo" or "check it out" (I read somewhere that the more times he says it before beginning his critique, the more he liked the performance, and that if you only get a "Yo baby", you should be very afraid". Interestingly, Simon Cowell's comments are still the ones that seem to mean the most to people - it doesn't seem to matter if the other 3 love you; if Simon ain't so keen, the face falls a bit.
They have free voting too, within the US, and as a result, a phenomenal number of votes are cast; I think last week something like 65 million people voted. I wonder if they charged like they do in this country whether quite so many people would vote. I am guessing not... It's quite mind-boggling to think of that many votes being cast - I think that is the point. It's votes cast, rather than people voting. I'll wager that a lot of people might be voting more than once.
The contestants all seem to be so much better than any of the contestants on British equivalents. Mind you, some of them have been appearing on stage and some of them have even released records, albeit ones that didn't sell that many (however few records they sold, it would still be more than my record).
Last week, the last remaining girl in the competition was eliminated. She was really good - she was only just 17, but she could rock that stage. It was a shame she had to go, but she went with a bang. Tonight it is down to the Top Three, and they are pretty different types of performer. There is Kris, who is terribly cute and plays guitar and has a rather sweet voice; there is Danny, who is kind of a white soul boy (Simon Cowell described him as sounding like Michael McDonald one week, which seemed pretty spot on), and who has been much ridiculed during the last week for a rather unfortunate attempt at hitting the high note at the end of Dream On, which came off more as a rather blood-curdling scream; and there is Adam, who is a little bit goth, a little bit emo, wears guyliner and nail varnish, has a very good voice and has grabbed most of the attention. Smart money would be on Danny and Adam making the final, but you just never know.
I can't really believe that I am so interested.
One thing that is possibly even more fascinating than the competition itself is dipping into some of the forums and discussion boards. They are crazy places. You get these Appreciation Threads where the users discuss the ins and outs of their favourites ad infinitum and in minute detail. And alongside that flies the vitriol. It can be quite scary how high the feelings run. One person's "Most Amazing Performance Ever" is the next person's "It Was So Horrible I Had To Mute The Sound". And then you get arguments as to whether one contestant is smug or not. Reading them, you realise that is all depends on your attitude to the person. If you don't really rate them or like them, then a smile can be smug; if you like the person, the exact same smile becomes too cute for words. Or one person's amazingly original interpretation is another's car crash moment.
It is endlessly fascinating.
Oh yeah, and Ryan Seacrest is quite cute.